About Work With Me AI Upfront Speaking Join Leveraging AI
AI UPFRONT·AI PRIVACY

Your AI Chats Aren’t Private: A Federal Judge Ruled Claude Chats Can Be Used in Court

A fraud defendant’s 31 conversations with Claude weren’t protected, because Claude isn’t a lawyer. Here’s what that means for you, and how to keep your AI chats on your own computer.

A wooden judge's gavel next to a black book on a dark surface
A federal judge ruled that a defendant’s AI chats about his case weren’t protected. Photo: Sasun Bughdaryan / Unsplash

A federal judge ruled that AI chat conversations are not private. Here’s what happened, and how to protect yourself.

Most of us ask AI legal questions. What does this contract mean? Can my landlord do that? But a ruling earlier this year makes one thing clear: what you type into a public AI tool isn’t protected the way a conversation with your lawyer is.

What did the judge actually rule?

Judge Jed Rakoff of the Southern District of New York ruled that a criminal defendant’s chats with Claude were not protected by attorney-client privilege or the work product doctrine. It’s the first ruling of its kind.

The defendant was Bradley Heppner, a financial executive charged in what prosecutors call a $150 million fraud scheme. After he knew he was under investigation, he used Claude to work through his case and outline defense strategies. When the FBI searched his home in November 2025, it seized approximately 31 documents memorializing those conversations.

Judge Rakoff ruled from the bench on February 10, 2026, and filed a written opinion on February 17.

Why weren’t the chats protected?

Because Claude isn’t a lawyer, and talking to it isn’t the same as talking to one.

The court gave a few reasons. Heppner’s chats weren’t communications with his attorney. Claude itself disclaims providing legal advice and tells users to consult a lawyer. Anthropic’s privacy policy reserves the right to share user data with third parties. And he did it on his own, not at the direction of his lawyers.

Sharing the chats with his lawyers afterward didn’t fix it, either.

What do people get wrong about this?

“It only matters if you’re a criminal.” The ruling came from a fraud case, but the reasoning is about the tool, not the person. Think about everyday questions like how to protect your assets in a divorce or how to get an insurance claim paid. Those chats aren’t protected just because they’re about legal topics.

“Turning off chat history keeps me safe.” Settings that stop a company from training on your chats don’t stop a court from ordering records.

“A local model makes my chats untouchable.” It doesn’t. In Heppner’s case, the FBI found the documents on his own devices. A local model keeps your chats off a company’s servers, but your own computer can still be searched or subpoenaed.

I’m not telling anyone to have conversations they shouldn’t. I’m telling you to know where your words go.

Dr. Erin Jacques

What’s changing

AI used to feel like a private notebook. Now a federal court has said it’s closer to talking to a third party.

That doesn’t mean you should stop using AI. It means you should choose where your most sensitive thinking happens.

How do you keep your AI chats private? Your move

One option is to run AI on your own computer, so your chats never sit on a company’s servers. Here’s the simplest way:

  1. Download LM Studio. It’s free for personal use at lmstudio.ai, and it works on Mac, Windows and Linux.
  2. Pick a model that fits your computer. With 8GB of memory, search “Llama 3.2 3B.” With 16GB or more, search “Qwen3 8B,” which is smarter and still fast. LM Studio shows how much memory each model needs before you download it.
  3. Start chatting. Once the model is downloaded, it works without the internet.
  4. For real legal questions, talk to a lawyer. Conversations with your attorney can be protected. Conversations with an AI tool on your own can’t.

Know the trade-offs: a model on your laptop isn’t as smart as ChatGPT or Claude, and it can’t search the internet. But you can give it your own files and ask questions about them without sending them anywhere.

This one gives you leverage: you keep using AI for sensitive work, without handing a company a copy of your thinking.

This isn’t legal advice. If you’re in a legal situation, talk to a lawyer.

Dr. Erin Jacques

Dr. Erin Jacques is a professor, AI strategist and the founder of Leveraging AI and ChatifyIT. She helps entrepreneurs and creators use AI safely and turn what they know into income.